“We Are Penn State”
An in-depth look at the design, welding, and construction of Penn State's celebrated WE ARE monument.
Behind the Sculpture: Penn State’s Stainless monument to healing and hope
As is the custom at Penn State University, alumni of the Class of 2013 made plans to provide a gift to the school, something to be enjoyed by future generations of students, faculty and visitors. What nobody knew at the time was that this gift would provide a path to healing from the wounds of the university’s recent past by recalling a time when its football program acted with honor and integrity.
In the autumn of 2011, the Penn State football program was rocked by a scandal so egregious that its aftereffects were felt not only by the team and students of the university, but throughout the NCAA, the country and around the world. The crimes for which assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky was convicted had the collateral effect of forever tarnishing the reputation of storied and celebrated football coach Joe Paterno and the program that was his life’s work.
In 2014, the alumni opened a design competition for a sculpture that would be prominently featured on campus. Among the entrants was noted metal sculptor and Penn State alumnus Jonathan Cramer (1994), who found the inspiration for his design in a largely unknown story that dated back to the segregated time of 1940s America.
“WE ARE! PENN STATE!” is a cheer heard during football games and other competitions that on its face seems so obvious that it needs no explanation. Cramer wanted to find the origins of the cheer. He discovered that in the 1970s, a group of cheerleaders got together and created the chant: “WE ARE! PENN STATE!” While an interesting tidbit of information, it was decidedly uninspiring. Cramer delved further into the history. What he uncovered was a deeper, more profound origin.
In the 1940s, football was far from immune to the fallout from racial segregation in the United States. In 1946, Penn State was invited to play at the University of Miami, with the caveat that
they leave their African-American players behind. Like most other southern schools at the time, Miami refused to compete against integrated teams.
The 1946 Penn State team had two African-American players on its roster, Dennie Hoggard and Wally Triplett. While the decision to play such a high profile game under Miami’s condition could have been an easy one for the predominantly white team, captain Steve Suhey put his teammates to a vote. The result, as reported to the coach, was unanimous: “We are Penn State. We play all or none.”
With that, the now-famous “WE ARE! PENN STATE!” cheer was born. Two years later, Penn State accepted an invitation to play in the Cotton Bowl and took its entire team, including Triplett and Hoggard, to Dallas, Texas. They became the first African-Americans to play in the Cotton Bowl. Triplett scored a touchdown as Penn State played Southern Methodist University to a 13-13 tie.
Both men would continue to make history. In 1949, the Detroit Lions made Triplett the first African-American selected in the NFL draft. Hoggard was the first African-American member of Lion’s Paw, an honorary society that recognizes service to the university and extracurricular activities.
Partnerships
In the 1940s, football was far from immune to the fallout from racial segregation in the United States. In 1946, Penn State was invited to play at the University of Miami, with the caveat that
they leave their African-American players behind. Like most other southern schools at the time, Miami refused to compete against integrated teams.
The 1946 Penn State team had two African-American players on its roster, Dennie Hoggard and Wally Triplett. While the decision to play such a high profile game under Miami’s condition could have been an easy one for the predominantly white team, captain Steve Suhey put his teammates to a vote. The result, as reported to the coach, was unanimous: “We are Penn State. We play all or none.”
With that, the now-famous “WE ARE! PENN STATE!” cheer was born. Two years later, Penn State accepted an invitation to play in the Cotton Bowl and took its entire team, including Triplett and Hoggard, to Dallas, Texas. They became the first African-Americans to play in the Cotton Bowl. Triplett scored a touchdown as Penn State played Southern Methodist University to a 13-13 tie.
Both men would continue to make history. In 1949, the Detroit Lions made Triplett the first African-American selected in the NFL draft. Hoggard was the first African-American member of Lion’s Paw, an honorary society that recognizes service to the university and extracurricular activities.
Armed with — and inspired by — the actual history of “WE ARE,” Cramer created a unique, asymmetrical design that was at the same time abstract and literal, winning the commission. Now, the goal of transforming raw material into a 12-foot-high monument to healing and hope had to be realized.
Cramer was no stranger to a commission of this scope. His prior works — including sculptures in New York City’s Central Park, Jersey City, New Jersey, and Providence, Rhode Island — are prominent and moving features. The Penn State commission had its own distinct challenges, both in terms of scale and material. According to Cramer, “Steel is unforgiving. It’s a slow process. It’s a dangerous process,” to coax an artist’s vision from the raw material. Cramer’s niche has always been the creation of geometric, abstract shapes which, when seen from different angles, appear differently, depending on the viewer’s point of view.
This element of abstraction was as evident in the asymmetry of the WE ARE sculpture as its underlying intent — a counterbalance to the intense adoration that could be foisted upon sports heroes and programs. According to the artist, “It’s a phrase! You can’t worship a phrase.” But Cramer says the sculpture makes people think about themselves in the context of humanity.
The challenges of the build were far less abstract.
Because of the not-always-happy weather in Happy Valley, where the campus is located, stainless steel was the obvious choice of construction material. Two-inch-thick slabs were sourced from a specialty mill in central Pennsylvania, not far from the university campus (Cramer insisted on American-made stainless steel).
Though Cramer describes stainless steel as “beautiful” and “incredible to work with,” it expands and contracts at different temperatures because it is comprised of different metals. “If you want to create intense precision with stainless steel while welding, you have to take into consideration heat sink and wicking away the heat, especially if your sculpture relies on perfect angles,” he says.
Three individual components of the structure were cut in the artist’s studio in Brooklyn, New York, where a team of welders, including the artist, undertook the arduous process of joining the pieces, including hours of welding 12-foot-long beads deep into the 2-inch-thick stainless steel.
Once welded, more than six months of hand polishing made the once dull stainless come to life, finally approaching the artist’s vision.
Nothing about this process was easy or could be taken for granted. The size and scale of the individual pieces required special rigging, even anchoring them to the floor of Cramer’s studio so they could be safely welded.
The sculpture was unveiled in 2015 with distinguished alumni, including Triplett, in attendance. (Hoggard died in 1985.)
Since its installation, the sculpture has become a touchstone to visitors to the campus and attracts tens of thousands of observers every year. It’s not uncommon for dozens of students to climb onto the sculpture at one time, especially after a Penn State football victory. It has also become a popular spot for graduating students to be photographed after commencement and a place where some alums have even exchanged wedding vows. “It has taken on an incredible role on campus,” Cramer points out.
The impact of the WE ARE sculpture can best be summed up by one of the men who became the inspiration of the phrase — Triplett. “Just a few words … there’s always that … where just a couple of words and you say to somebody, with pride, “WE ARE! PENN STATE!”