Ask the Experts
Professional welders explain wire selection, weld appearance, travel speed, shielding gas considerations, and practical welding techniques for improved results.
I have a small Lincoln Electric wire feed unit that I use for light repairs around the farm (hay rings, exhaust pipes, etc.). The recommended wire gauge for the machine is .035 flux-core, but the local store where I buy my consumables was out of .035, so I grabbed a spool of .030 flux-core instead. After a few adjustments for the heat and wire feed speed, I found that I was getting better penetration and more consistent bead uniformity than I had with the thicker wire. There seemed to be less spatter, and the slag was much easier to knock off with a wire brush. Given this discovery, I see no reason why I would use the .035 wire in the future. Can you explain why this different gauge works so much better?
Jason Mocarsky, Halifax, Virginia
NR211 .035 and NR211 .035 both have a maximum thickness of 5/16, which is within the acceptable range for that type of machine. You have more range of adjustment with the smaller wire than the larger wire for a given wire feed speed (WFS) and voltage setting. So your machine is designed to operate at only so much voltage and amperage. Those factors will not change. What does change is the amperage reading, depending on the size of the wire you use (smaller versus larger) at the same WFS.
For the NR211MP .035 wire, the amperage range is 30 amps at 50 WFS to 155 amps at 275 WFS, and the voltage range is 14 to 21 volts. For the NR211MP .030 wire, the amperage range is 30 amps at 50 WFS to 140 amps at 300 WFS, and the voltage range is 13 to 19 volts. As you can see, the WFS changes the amperage draw considerably. As long as you adjust your wire and voltage to what the machine can give you, there really isn’t much difference. The only difference is that you have a greater WFS to do the same work as the .035 setting. Try and run the same amps and voltage – not WFS – for both wires and see if you notice a difference. Both wires will run the amperage with different WFS and voltage. However, you cannot go beyond the amperage draw no matter what wire you use, or you will exceed the duty cycle of the machine.
I have seen different variations of color while TIG welding stainless steel art – anything from red to blue to green, etc. What factors determine these color variations? Is it temperature, penetration, just plain luck or some other factor?
Jason Beard, Norwalk, Ohio
The difference in color has to do with lack of shielding gas coverage. Oxides form where there is no gas coverage. The more atmosphere allowed into the weld will cause more color. This doesn’t necessarily mean the weld is bad. Generally, though, the color dictates how bad the weld is. You want a yellowish color to clear. When you starting getting into such colors as blue, dark blue, white or gray, it’s an indication of a lot of oxide, which will deplete the mechanical properties of the weld. If you correctly purge, the weld should be clear. The same applies to welding titanium. Before a weld is approved on titanium, the color is examined. Welds that are glossy silver, light straw and dark straw are acceptable, while purple, blue, yellow and gray are unacceptable. Brushed welds are also unacceptable.
Is there a widely accepted rate that’s considered the optimal travel speed for MIG welding? Or is it merely a case of practice and experience until the operator finds the most suitable speed for the settings and the material being welded?
Matt Clough, Berkshire, England, UK
There are a lot of variables to consider, including what you’re running, what mode you’re running, how thick or thin is the material, and what direction are you’re traveling. Vertical up is always slower than vertical down. Thin materials will always run faster than thicker materials. Spray arcs are high-energy arcs that travel fast, while short arcs are low-energy and travel more slowly. Sometimes gas blends will increase or decrease travel speeds. It’s a matter of watching the puddle, knowing its size, and practice. That comes with experience.
When MIG welding, is there any benefit to whipping or weaving. Does it increase penetration or create a more aesthetically pleasing weld?
Matt Clough, Berkshire, England, UK
There is really no benefit to whipping or weaving. In reality, you don’t want to move too far out of the puddle because you lose gas shielding. Too much movement or too much distance between the weld and the nozzle will result in less effective gas coverage and a weld integrity problem. As long as you stay within the gas coverage, you can manipulate the weld somewhat, but whipping way in or way out will cause oxides and porosity. It’s no different than pulling the filler metal in and out during TIG welding. In addition, too much movement during MIG welding will change the contact tip-to-work distance on the wire, which will cause spatter. There’s an acceptable margin for a small amount of movement, but not too much.
From the welding experts at
Lincoln Electric