Question Mark
Veteran educator and welding engineer Mark Prosser provides practical answers to common welding challenges, helping welders improve safety, quality, and performance.
What is back-step welding and why do we do it?
Back-step welding is a technique that helps to greatly reduce distortion, especially in thinner materials. The weld is broken down into smaller weld segments as opposed to one solid weld all the way across the weld joint. Back-step welding is also done in a different direction than a regular weld. The idea is to divide the weld into smaller welds, which gives the material a minute to cool. But the added benefit to back-step welding is that it also counteracts the shrinkage forces created by a weld.
Back-step welding requires a higher skill level – and a little more time – to tie in to each end of the smaller weld segments. When back-step welding, instead of starting the weld at one end and running it to the other, we start the weld more in the middle of the weld joint and run a small weld from the middle to the end, then “back up” and run the next weld from a start point to into the starting end of the previous weld.
The overall length of the weld joint will determine how many back-step welds we put in the joint. Back-step welds can be a very effective technique to reduce distortion and stress in the weld.
Can I weld through galvanized coating?
Galvanized coating provides an excellent corrosion protection for materials. It has been used for many years to prolong the natural deterioration processes that affect steel over time. Galvanized parts are usually hot dipped or electroplated with the coating, and the thicknesses differ depending on the intended application of the parts. The issue when welding through any coating (paint, galvanized, powder coat) is that it creates problems with weld integrity. Welding over coatings causes porosity in the weld, lack of fusion, and weld contamination that can greatly reduce the integrity of the weld.
We all know that a cleaner weld makes for a better weld, so welding over coatings is not recommended. The coating needs to be removed from the weld joint area. However, once the coating is removed and the weld joint is created, the uncoated area needs to be recoated to ensure that the material doesn’t rust.
The bigger problem with welding galvanized coatings is the fumes that are generated when the coating is burned. Galvanized coatings are made of zinc, which creates toxic zinc oxide fumes when welded. Inhalation of the fumes causes flu-like symptoms and can lead to zinc poisoning, commonly known as “metal fume fever.” Before welding galvanized parts, the coating must be removed from the weld area to avoid exposure to these fumes. Proper ventilation is key, and in some operations, a respirator is a necessity. The most important priority when welding any coated piece is to remove the coating from the weld joint and be sure to have proper ventilation, but this rule is particularly important when welding galvanized parts.
How do I identify magnesium, and how does it differ from aluminum in the welding process?
Magnesium is a versatile material that has been used for many years in many different industries. It is an alloy comprised of aluminum, zinc, manganese, and zirconium. These are rare earth metals that can be as strong as steel but four times lighter and two thirds lighter than aluminum. There are certain challenges associated with welding this material, but the first challenge is the ability to identify it. Magnesium looks and feels much like aluminum, and as such, it can easily be mistaken for aluminum.
The easiest way to determine if a part is aluminum or magnesium is with just a bit of household vinegar. Put a few drops of vinegar on the part and watch for a reaction. If the part is aluminum, there will be no reaction. But if the part is magnesium, the vinegar will react with the alloy and create a foam.
The preferred process for welding magnesium is TIG. It welds much like aluminum – but a dirty aluminum in a sense, due to all of the alloying agents it contains. Much like aluminum, magnesium creates an oxide layer on its surface. And much like aluminum, the oxide layer needs to be removed before welding. This is done with AC current. The oxide layer on magnesium melts at a much higher temperature than the base metal.
The zinc content in magnesium requires a tight arc length, which calls for a bit more skill than what is necessary with welding aluminum. Many magnesium parts are castings that are porous and can absorb oils and fluids, which can make it difficult to weld. There are several different types of magnesium, so one filler or technique might not work with another. As always, do your research and make some practice runs before attempting to make the weld.
One other important issue to consider when welding magnesium is the metal's high level of ignitability. Magnesium is a combustible material and the dust/small particulate forms can pose a flash fire risk. Note that a Class D fire extinguisher is required to put out a fire. Magnesium will burn in water. Proper combustible dust housekeeping protocols are required to minimize fire risk when dust and shavings are generated.
Should I change my machine settings with welding position?
There are many opinions about this. In general, we adjust a machine based on the thickness of the material not on the weld position. Assuming the welding machine is set up and adjusted correctly, we need to understand what happens when we change welding positions. First, there are welding techniques that are used in some positions that are not used in other positions. For example, we generally don’t use weave beads in the horizontal position because it’s very easy to lose fusion. That’s not to say that it can’t be done, but generally we don’t use that technique in the position.
Some operators readjust their machines to help control the puddle in different positions. However, I personally would argue that there are better ways to control the puddle and heat input – especially if the machine is positioned a long distance from the operator. If the machine is correctly adjusted for the material, different welding techniques can be used to control the puddle rather than machine adjustment.
Bottom line, we are trying to control the weld puddle in different welding positions. To do this, we first need to understand how gravity affects the weld puddle. When you consider how gravity pulls the molten puddle in different positions, you can then adjust your welding technique to counteract the pull on the liquid puddle from the joint.
Reducing heat input gives us more time to manipulate the puddle in different welding positions, but there are different ways to lower heat input besides adjusting the machine. Adjusting your arc length or travel speed are options. In the end, creating high-quality welds is the priority, and if readjusting your machine helps you in different welding positions, by all means do it. But there are instances where it may be more practical – and easier – to change your technique for heat control rather than changing your machine settings.